Bob Dylan’s best songs: “When The Night Comes Falling From The Sky” #113

Bob Dylan Bootleg_series_1-3

Composing it [When The Night Comes Falling From The Sky], yeah. Um… you know, it was bits and pieces of different places that went into writing that. Lines overheard here and there, you know, strung together over a long period of time, resulted in that particular piece.
~Bob Dylan (to Eliot Mintz – March 1991)

…Dylan sings wonderfully. The songs seems capable of kicking itself into even-higher gear, and as the band recognizes it, so does Dylan, who gets audibly more and more excited as the song progresses
~John Bauldie (about the TBS 1-3 version)

 

@ #113 on my list of Dylan’s 200 best songs.. and this is the “Bootleg Series 1-3” version…. the Empire Burlesque version is nowhere near my top 200…

This version was recorded @

Studio A
The Power Station
New York City, New York
19 February 1985
Empire Burlesque recording session

The band included 2 “E-streeter’s”: Roy Bittan & Little “Stevie” Van Zandt..

  • Bob Dylan (guitar, vocal)
  • Roy Bittan (piano)
  • Robbie Shakespeare (bass)
  • Sly Dunbar (drums)
  • Queen Ester Marrow, Debra Byrd, Carolyn Dennis (backing vocals).
  • Steve van Zandt (guitar)

Spotify:

bob dylan 1985

Beginning on low simmer, Dylan doesn’t start cooking until the band join in – on ‘I can see through your walls…’ However, once he sits full square on the hot-plate, he bellows like a wild wolf.
~Clinton Heylin (Still On The Road)

Lyrics

If you look out across the fields, see me returning.
Smoke is in your eyes, you draw a smile.
From the fireplace where now my letters to you are burning,
You’ve had time to think about it for a while.

I’ve walked two hundred miles, now look me over.
It’s the end of the chase and the moon is high.
It don’t matter who loves who.
Either you’ll love me or I’ll love you
When the night comes falling from the sky.

I can see through your walls and I know you’re hurting.
Sorrow covers you up like a cape.
Only yesterday I know that you’ve been flirting
With disaster that you somehow managed to escape.

Well, I can’t provide for you no easy answers.
Who are you that I should have to lie?
You know everything, my love.
Down below and up above.
When the night comes falling from the sky.

I can hear your trembling heart beat like a river.
And recently you thought you’d seen it all.
But you’re disappointed now in those who did not deliver.
But it was you who set yourself up for a fall.

I’ve seen thousands who could have overcome the darkness,
For the love of a lousy buck, I’ve watched them die.
Stick around, baby, we’re not through,
Don’t look for me, I’ll see you.
When the night comes falling from the sky.

In your teardrops, I can see my own reflection.
Luck was with me when I crossed the borderline.
I don’t want to be a fool that’s starving for affection.
I don’t want to drown in someone else’s wine.

For all eternity I think I will remember
That whirlpool of light that’s in your eye.
You will seek me and you’ll find
Me in the wasteland of your mind.
When the night comes falling from the sky.

Well, I gave to you my heart like buried treasure
But suffering seems to fit you like a glove
I’m so tired of those who use for their own pleasure
Who think they’ve got a monopoly on love

Well, this time I’m asking for freedom,
Freedom from a world which you deny.
And you’ll give it to me now,
I’ll take it anyhow.
When the night comes falling from the sky.

Live

The song has been performed 63 times live; 55 times in 1986 & 8 times in 1987.

Here are two..

Entertainment Centre
Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
24 February 1986

Civic Center Auditorium
Hartford, Connecticut
11 July 1986

Check out:

-Egil

12 thoughts on “Bob Dylan’s best songs: “When The Night Comes Falling From The Sky” #113”

  1. Best song? Hardly. Not even close. The phrasing is terrible, the title is boring. Yes, the bootleg series version is a bit more interesting, but only a bit. I heard him do it live at Madison Square Garden in 1986 and didn’t care much for that one either. Sorry but praising a second rate work isn’t healthy for anybody. I wish this site had more critical thinking.

    1. the 113th best song – that close to being the best song.

      To write about stuff we don’t like is a waste of time. We’re not music critics we’re music lovers.

      “I can not be a critic, I love art too much”
      – Martin Scorsese

      You want negative reviews, well yes, you have to go elsewhere.

      About Us (“The mission statement”):
      “We don’t write about music we don’t like, we don’t listen to music we don’t like, we don’t attend concerts we don’t like. But we sometimes write about “not so good” music from artists we really like. Most great artists have a diverse body of work, and it’s important to shed a light over different parts of their legacy.”

      Anyway, thanks for the comment. 🙂

  2. Although I don’t like the production of the Empire Burlesque version, especially considering the drums, I feel the E Street version is a bit conservative, just plain rock, more in the macho vein of Bruce, whereas on Empire he takes chances, tries out something completely new and sings as if the devil is on his heels. Okay, it is dated now, this disco treatment, but it cooks and could have sounded better with less compression and diddling with echo and phasing. The lyrics too are much improved upon, the way he pronounces Icy Wind is just chilling, whereas the whirlwind of light has no power to convince. I cherish this song, despite the loathsome eighties treatment, because of the content and the singing… and because it is Dylan experimenting, a thing Bruce seldom did, but okay that great man never convinced me, but I see why people like him.

  3. I’m pretty sure it’s “I’m so tired of those who use for their own pleasure” which is what I hear. Bob probably didn’t release the awesome version because of the “Springsteen” sound (great piano) – not the sound an aging superstar considered over the hill would want in the Bruce explosion of 1985.

    1. Thanks for another great comment AWFF,

      I agree. The “Lyrics” will be corrected. … nice observation!

      Roy Bittan’s playing is wonderful… as on so many Springsteen tracks & live performances..

      -Egil

  4. Your posting of the various live and studio versions of this song brings to my mind a suggestion that I would like to see the Bootleg series pursue: take one song in the Dylan corpus, issuing a CD called “Transformation” consisting of the original studio version and a large number of live versions. The point would be to show how Dylan transforms a song, creating multiple versions that contradict or expand on the intention of the original. Take for instance “Like a Rolling Stone” that Dylan turned into its opposite (from the studio version) at the Isle of Wight concert. One could relate this to his painting where he transforms a picture by choosing different colors to create different moods. In music changing the key, the instruments, the rhythm, the ambiance in turns of the introduction into the song, fills the same functions.

    1. Thanks for commenting Carl,

      Such a “Bootleg series” release would have been great!
      As I mentioned in an earlier comment.. SONY should speed up their bootleg series release frequency… what about a release each month 🙂

      -Egil

  5. Great post…in my opinion the song really came alive on the road with TP&tHB’s in ’86. The “Hard to Handle” version is tops.

    1. Thanks for your comment Bernard,

      It existed.. and the recording session was for “Empire Burlesque” 🙂

      … and I agree.. The “EB-version” is crap.

      -Egil

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *